Shovel vs. Spade: What’s the Difference?
You’ve heard both terms and probably used both tools, but if someone asked you to hand them one, could you pull the right one out of the shed? And depending on which side of the Atlantic you’re on, the answer might be different.
Having the right tool for the job makes gardening easier on you and better for your garden. In this article, we’ll break down the differences between shovels and spades, and look at the different types, so you know which one to reach for and when.
Terminology
Shovel and spade are often used interchangeably. While they occupy very similar roles and can perform many of the same functions, they have some fundamental differences that give them distinct advantages.
It can be helpful to think of a spade as a knife and a shovel as a spoon. Both are useful for eating, but each is better suited to certain jobs. Knives are great for cutting, and less useful for lifting, whereas spoons are great for lifting, and can still cut through softer foods. In the same way, a pointed shovel can dig into tough ground, but it won’t give you the clean edge of a spade. A spade, on the other hand, is flat, so you’ll move less material with each lift.
In the US, both terms are used, but “shovel” often serves as a catch-all for almost any digging tool. In the UK, the two are more commonly treated as clearly separate tools. In this article, we’ll use the traditional definitions.
Shovels
There are three main types of shovels:
- Round-point
- Square-point
- Scoop
Round-Point Shovels
Round-point shovels are common in the garden, and perhaps most often confused with spades. Their pointed tip lets them break into hard or compacted soil, and the scooped profile means they can hold a lot of material.
If you need to dig a large hole, such as for planting a tree or shrub, this is an excellent tool for the job.
Square-Point Shovels
Square-point shovels are great for transferring materials from place to place, such as from a compost heap into a wheelbarrow. Because they lack a point, they’re less suited for digging, but their flat edge is ideal for scraping material off hard surfaces, like clearing a patio or driveway, and for leveling soil or gravel.
Compared with a scoop shovel, their smaller size also helps you avoid lifting too much at once. For certain jobs, it can be helpful to loosen material with a round-point shovel, then move it with a square-point shovel, saving you time and energy.
Scoop Shovels
Scoop shovels have deep, rounded profiles and often a shorter handle than round- or square-point shovels. These tools are great for moving loose, lightweight materials such as mulch, hay, and feed. They’re popular for clean-up tasks, and the taller sides help keep material from falling out. Avoid using them for heavy materials like wet soil or gravel, as a full scoop can quickly become too heavy to lift safely.
Scoop shovels have a variety of unusual applications. Patio flooded with a shallow layer of water? A scoop shovel is an effective tool to scoop it away.
In short, reach for a round-point shovel for digging, a square-point shovel for moving and scraping, and a scoop shovel for bulky, lightweight materials.
Spades
Spades are precise digging tools. There are four main types for garden use:
- Digging spades
- Border spades
- Pointed spades
- Transplanting spades
Digging Spades
Digging spades typically have a flat, rectangular blade with a straight or slightly rounded bottom edge. They lack the distinct curved profile of shovels, though some do have a gentle curve to aid material removal.
Digging spades are excellent for turning soil and slicing cleanly through soil and roots. Flat-profile spades are also good for tidying up lawn edges and for lifting and cutting turf.
Border Spades
If you work with borders a lot in your garden, this tool can help considerably. Border spades are almost identical to digging spades, but are shorter, lighter, and narrower. This makes them excellent for dense plantings or for working between tree roots, where you want to disturb the surrounding ground as little as possible. Their flat blade slices cleanly through soil, giving you more control than a shovel over how much is removed or loosened.
Pointed Spades
These are perhaps the most like shovels. They’re spades, but they have a sharpened, narrow tip that helps drive the blade easily through hard-packed, stony soil and deep into the ground.
Their narrow blade makes them great for tight spaces, and they can create even holes or continuous trenches in your planting areas.
Transplanting Spades
These are a little less common, but they’re well worth having. Transplanting spades have a long, narrow blade, often slightly curved, and a sharpened edge, sometimes serrated, to cut cleanly through dense roots. This lets you lift plants with their root ball intact, and makes them wonderfully useful for dividing perennials too.
Transplanting spades are often sold as drain spades because they're incredibly useful for digging narrow, defined holes. They’re also the least likely to be flat, as their curved or V-shaped blades help slice narrow sections of soil out of the ground.
In short, reach for a digging spade for turning and cutting soil, a border spade for tight beds, a pointed spade for hard ground and trenches, and a transplanting spade for moving and dividing plants.
Which to Have?
It can be impractical to own a lot of garden tools. Between storage space, cost, and maintenance, less is often more.
A digging spade is an excellent all-rounder for digging, planting, and edging. Some gardeners prefer a spade with a slightly rounded edge, but flat-edged ones are great too. Pair it with a round-point shovel, and you have tools that are great for both digging and moving material.
A scoop shovel is handy for moving mulch, compost, and clean-up jobs, and together, these three make a valuable arsenal for your shed.
The best combination depends on how you garden. Listing the jobs you do most often can help you decide which tools are worth having.
Wrapping Up
Knowing the differences between shovels and spades can make gardening easier. By choosing the right tool for the task at hand, you can work more efficiently and reduce strain on your body. Look out for our upcoming article on choosing garden tools, where we’ll cover materials, handles, and what to look for when buying.
Put away the pen and paper
Plan your veggie garden in minutes with Planter's easy drag and drop planner.
Try Planter for Free